Once upon a time, and not so very long ago, God created this island, ‘Short Beach,’ or ‘Flat Beach’ later known as Tucker’s Island.  For it was Ephraim Morse who first settled there in the mid 1700’s and decades later sold the land to Reuben Tucker.  It was Tucker who later developed the Island into one of New Jersey’s first resorts back in the late 1700’s, called Sea Haven! Avid wild-game hunters and fishermen sojourned by stagecoach and then by boat to  retreat there.  As interest grew, hotels, homes and schools were built as well as the famous Tucker’s Lighthouse.

But,  there’s no happy ending to this tale.  In due time the constant pounding of the Atlantic Ocean, and violent storms reclaimed this quaint tract of paradise.  Bit by bit the island surrendered it’s land and buildings to the sea, and eventually the light house crumbled late in 1927.  Fortunately, the folk tales, and fables live on, and are shared by the indigenous families who still reside in the area.

What has recently surfaced, however, are over forty original Deeds/Indentures, and Surveys of the streets and lots that were developed on the Island.  We, at Legacies Old and New, are so excited to offer these exceptional, one of a kind, items to the general public at auction!  What a rare opportunity to own a piece of history!

The following is a short list of items on the auction block from Tucker’s Island as well as Long Beach Island and surrounding areas:

UNIQUELY NJ COASTAL:  Featuring, Bond’s Life-Saving Service Badge, Surveys: Tucker’s Island/Flat Beach Surveys; Deeds, Bonds & Warrants: Over thirty Tucker’s Island/Flat Beach Deeds; plus U.S. Miniature Models of Japanese Navy – Sup. #1; Local Ephemera: Property Owners/Beach Haven Book of Street Maps, Plan of North Beach Haven Map ca 1920’s.30’s; List of Deeds compiled for David J. Pancoast, Special Master regarding lawsuit of bankruptcy of the Sea Haven Corporation (November 1894), Bill on Riparian Rights (1927), Sea Haven Improvement, Beach Haven Heights, Coast and Inland Development, Beach Haven Land, Edgewater Beach Realty, Beach Haven Heights, Coast and Inland Development Companies, & Tuckerton Railroad Letterhead, Invoices etc.  Promotional Pamphlets/Booklets:  Beach Haven Heights, Long Beach Island New Jersey 1930, Brant Beach The Gem of the Ocean Front, Spray Beach, Beach Haven New Jersey and the Lure of the Sea 1929, Little Egg Harbor Yacht Club, New Jersey Bell 1952, Robert R. Osborn Realty; Stock Certificates/Shares: Brant Beach Realty Co., Padgett’s Boat Basin, Beacon-Times Newspapers, Shore Fun Rentals, Barnegat Light Yacht Basin, Terrace Fish Co., George Willits Parker, Inc., & Bill’s Restaurant; Photographs: Elizabeth V. Edwards School Class Photos, Cabinet Cards of Gaskill, Errickson & Van Cleaf Families of Barnegat, Beach Haven ca 1860, Southern Regional’s Basket Ball 1st two points scored in basketball history photo, Beach Haven Baseball Team Picture, 1944 Hurricane Destruction; Books: Bibles & Hymn Books of Sprague Family, Autograph Book ca 1879 Barnegat, ‘Tides of Time’ by Ocean County Principals Council 1940, ‘Under Barnegat’s Beam” by B. Kraft, ‘The Lure of Long Beach New Jersey’ by Long Beach Board of Trade, ‘The Tuckerton Railroad’ by J. Brinckmann, ‘The Tides of Barnegat’ by F. Smith, ‘History of Little Egg Harbor Township’ by L. Blackman, Barnegat & Southern H.S. Year Books (ca. 1951’s-1955); Bottles: (Barnegat, Bridgeton, Cranberry, Egg Harbor, Jersey City, Ocean City, Toms River); Miscellaneous: Masonic Mariners Lodge No. 150 (Clayton Corliss) Ribbon/Badge, Central Ice Company Pick & Receipt, Long Beach Island License Plate Toppers.

In addition to the historical documents offered, we will also be auctioning vintage Toys, Dolls & Banks; Pottery & Glass; Navajo Indian Pottery, Rugs & Blankets; Folk Art & Primitives; loads of items for the Home and so much more.  We invite you to join us…

Multi-Estate Auction
Saturday, March 25
Auction Preview 8:00 a.m. day of sale or Friday by Appointment (609.618.7216)
Auction Commences at 9:00 a.m.
Eagleswood Fire Hall
219 Railroad Ave.
West Creek, NJ 08092

Visit our picture Gallery & Auction Listing as well as Terms of Sale.  Unable to attend? Follow the links on our website and register to bid as an absentee bidder.